Skip to content

Get the app

Study guide · Retail Securities Exam · Element 7

Investment recommendations

14 of the Retail Securities Exam's questions · 12 learning outcomes · 7 topics

Element 7 covers making investment recommendations: linking a client's objectives and risk profile to performance, non-financial constraints, behavioural biases, suitable product selection and portfolio choice, investment actions and the recommendation process, time value of money for financial goals, personal and corporate tax planning, capital gains and investment income tax, and complaint handling. CIRO's syllabus gives it about 14 of the Retail Securities Exam's 120 questions. Most questions are client vignettes: they test whether you can choose the best course for the client, calculate savings and annuity amounts, work out capital gains and the tax on interest and dividends, and handle a complaint correctly.

A study feature written by ExamDragon, not part of the real exam. CIRO publishes the element, its question count and its learning outcomes (listed below); the 7 topics are ours and cover every outcome.

CIRO's 12 learning outcomes for this element
  1. 7.1Analyze the relationship between a client's investment objectives and needs, risk profile and performance.
  2. 7.2Analyze the impact of a client placing non-financial constraints and restrictions on their own investment choices.
  3. 7.3Understand principles of behavioural finance and the potential impact on a client's decisions and returns.
  4. 7.4Apply retail client suitability determination requirements to specific situations.
  5. 7.5Apply relevant processes to choose a portfolio for the client, based on their know-your-client (KYC) information.
  6. 7.6Apply relevant factors to specific situations in addressing investment actions for a client.
  7. 7.7Analyze the key requirements of the investment action recommendation process.
  8. 7.8Apply the time value of money calculation in setting financial goals for the client.
  9. 7.9Apply the basics of personal and corporate tax planning in relation to investment recommendation scenarios.
  10. 7.10Apply the basics of the Canadian capital gains tax system to a client's investment gains.
  11. 7.11Apply the basics of the Canadian income tax system to income from a client's investments.
  12. 7.12Apply to specific situations the regulatory requirements governing complaints handling.

IR-1Objectives, constraints and behavioural finance

  • A client's objectives (safety, income, growth, or a mix), needs and risk profile set the range of expected performance: a conservative profile means lower expected returns and smaller swings, and the client should understand that trade-off before investing.
  • Performance must be judged against what the portfolio was designed to do; a balanced portfolio that trails an all-equity index in a strong market may still be meeting the client's objectives.
  • Non-financial constraints, such as ESG criteria, equity, diversity and inclusion screens or personal preferences (avoiding certain industries), are part of KYC and must be respected; they may narrow the investment universe and change diversification, cost and expected return, which should be explained to the client.
  • Cognitive biases are errors in reasoning, such as anchoring on a purchase price, confirmation bias (seeking only agreeing information) and mental accounting (treating money differently by source).
  • Information-processing biases distort how facts are used, such as framing (a choice changes with how it is presented), availability (overweighting recent or vivid events) and representativeness (judging by stereotypes or short track records).
  • Emotional biases come from feelings, such as loss aversion (feeling losses more than equal gains), overconfidence, regret aversion and status quo bias; capital market biases include herding and chasing recent winners, which can feed bubbles. A representative who recognizes these can help a client avoid costly decisions.
  1. The situationSofia refuses to sell a stock that has fallen from CAD 50 to CAD 30 and no longer fits her plan, saying she will sell once it gets back to CAD 50.
  2. Step 1Fixing on the CAD 50 purchase price is anchoring; refusing to accept a loss is loss aversion.
  3. Step 2The relevant question is whether the stock, at CAD 30, is the best use of that money for her goals today.
  4. Step 3The representative reframes the decision around future prospects and her objectives, not around the past price.
  5. Step 4The discussion and Sofia's decision are documented, whatever she decides.
  6. Where questions turnTreating ESG or other preferences as optional extras: they are part of the client's KYC and must be respected in recommendations.
  7. The takeawayRecognizing a bias by name helps move the conversation from the past price to the client's goals.
Practise Investment recommendations

IR-2Suitable products and choosing a portfolio

  • Suitable product selection means choosing, from the reasonable range of products on the firm's shelf, the one that best fits the client's KYC, considering cost; if the shelf is limited (for example to proprietary products), the client must have been told so.
  • Net worth and liquidity guide how much can be invested and how much must stay accessible; an emergency fund of cash or cash equivalents, such as savings accounts, money market funds or high interest savings products, comes before long-term investing.
  • A defined benefit pension promises a set income in retirement, which raises a client's risk capacity; a defined contribution plan or group RRSP leaves the investment risk with the employee and must be counted as part of the client's overall portfolio.
  • Choosing a portfolio starts with the client's needs and risk profile, reviews the current portfolio, and identifies any shortfall between what the client has and what the goals require.
  • A cash flow analysis (income minus expenses) shows how much the client can save regularly and whether goals are realistic; where goals and risk profile conflict, the representative discusses options such as saving more, extending the horizon or adjusting the goal.
  • The chosen strategy is set out as an asset mix and implementation plan the client understands and agrees to.
  1. The situationOmar, 45, earns CAD 9,000 a month after tax and spends CAD 7,400. He has CAD 3,000 in his chequing account, no other savings, and wants to start investing in equities.
  2. Step 1Monthly surplus = 9,000 minus 7,400 = CAD 1,600 available to save.
  3. Step 2With only CAD 3,000 of cash, he lacks an emergency fund, so liquidity comes first.
  4. Step 3A suitable plan directs savings first to an emergency fund in cash equivalents, then to a diversified portfolio matching his risk profile.
  5. Step 4The representative documents the cash flow analysis and the reasons for the order of steps.
  6. Where questions turnIgnoring a client's pension or group plan when building the portfolio, which misjudges both risk capacity and overall asset mix.
  7. The takeawayCash flow and liquidity come before the investment choice; suitability starts with the client's whole financial picture.
Practise Investment recommendations

IR-3Investment actions and the recommendation process

  • A significant change in KYC, such as a job loss, inheritance, marriage or a shorter time horizon, calls for a review and may call for changes to the portfolio.
  • Concentration in one security, issuer or sector, and illiquid holdings, raise risk; a recommendation should consider reducing them, while weighing taxes on realized gains and the client's reasons for holding.
  • The impact of costs, such as commissions, fund fees, early redemption charges and taxes, is part of every recommendation, and reasonable alternative actions, including doing nothing, should be compared.
  • A good recommendation explains what the action achieves for the client, its advantages and disadvantages, its risks and costs, and how it compares with alternatives, in terms the client understands.
  • The client's commitment is secured only after the client understands and agrees; the recommendation, the reasons and the client's instructions are documented.
  1. The situationClaire, 60, holds 55% of her CAD 600,000 portfolio in shares of her former employer, which she plans to rely on for retirement income in five years.
  2. Step 1Her employer's shares are worth 55% x 600,000 = CAD 330,000, a heavy concentration in one issuer.
  3. Step 2A five year horizon to retirement income lowers her risk capacity, so the concentration is a key risk.
  4. Step 3The representative recommends reducing the position gradually, weighing the capital gains tax on the sale against the risk, and explains the alternatives, including holding.
  5. Step 4Claire's decision and the reasons are documented, and the plan is carried out over time if she agrees.
  6. Where questions turnRecommending a sale to reduce concentration without discussing the tax and cost consequences and the alternatives.
  7. The takeawayA recommendation weighs risk reduction against costs and taxes, explains the alternatives and secures the client's informed agreement.
Practise Investment recommendations

IR-4Time value of money for financial goals

  • Future value of a single sum = PV x (1 + i) to the power n; present value = FV / (1 + i) to the power n.
  • Regular savings for a future goal (end-of-period payments): PMT = FV x i / [(1 + i) to the power n minus 1].
  • Regular income from a single investment (an annuity paid at the end of each period): PMT = PV x i / [1 minus (1 + i) to the power minus n].
  • Payments at the start of each period (an annuity due) earn one extra period of interest, so the required savings are smaller, or the income larger, than for end-of-period payments.
  • Match the period of the rate to the payments: for monthly payments, use the monthly rate and the number of months.
  • A real (after-inflation) rate can be used to express goals in today's dollars; ignoring inflation understates how much a client needs to save.
  1. The situationAnita wants CAD 50,000 in 10 years for a home renovation and expects to earn 5% a year. A separate client, Tom, has CAD 200,000 and wants equal annual income for 20 years at 4%.
  2. Step 1Anita: PMT = 50,000 x 0.05 / [(1.05) to the power 10 minus 1] = 2,500 / (1.6289 minus 1) = 2,500 / 0.6289 = CAD 3,975 a year.
  3. Step 2Over 10 years she deposits 3,975 x 10 = CAD 39,750; interest makes up the rest.
  4. Step 3Tom: PMT = 200,000 x 0.04 / [1 minus (1.04) to the power minus 20] = 8,000 / (1 minus 0.4564) = 8,000 / 0.5436 = CAD 14,716 a year.
  5. Step 4Both answers assume end-of-year payments and a constant return.
  6. Where questions turnUsing annual rates with monthly payments: the rate and the number of periods must match the payment frequency.
  7. The takeawayUse the sinking fund formula to save toward a goal and the annuity formula to draw income from a lump sum.
Practise Investment recommendations

IR-5Personal and corporate tax planning

  • RRSP contributions are deductible from income, growth is tax-deferred, and withdrawals are taxed as income; an RRSP must be converted, for example to a RRIF or an annuity, by the end of the year the holder turns 71, and a RRIF has required minimum withdrawals.
  • TFSA contributions are not deductible, but growth and withdrawals are tax free; amounts withdrawn are added back to contribution room on 1 January of the following year, and over-contributions are taxed.
  • Contributing to a spousal RRSP can split retirement income, but withdrawals are taxed in the contributor's hands if a spousal contribution was made in the year of withdrawal or the two previous calendar years. Other registered plans include the FHSA for a first home and the RESP for education savings.
  • To minimize tax in non-registered accounts, Canadian eligible dividends and capital gains are taxed more lightly than interest, so interest-bearing investments are often better placed in registered accounts; tax-loss selling realizes losses to offset gains.
  • Attribution rules generally tax income and gains on money given or lent to a spouse back to the giver, so simple transfers do not split income.
  • A Canadian-controlled private corporation's investment income is taxed at a high rate, part of which is refundable (tracked in refundable dividend tax on hand) when the corporation pays taxable dividends; the non-taxable half of its capital gains goes to the capital dividend account and can be paid to shareholders tax free; the general rate income pool tracks income that can be paid out as eligible dividends.
  1. The situationA client has CAD 20,000 in a GIC paying interest and CAD 20,000 in Canadian dividend-paying shares. She has unused TFSA room for only one of them.
  2. Step 1Interest is fully taxable at her marginal rate in a non-registered account.
  3. Step 2Eligible Canadian dividends receive the dividend tax credit, so they are taxed more lightly.
  4. Step 3Placing the GIC in the TFSA shelters the most heavily taxed income.
  5. Step 4The dividend shares stay in the non-registered account, where the dividend tax credit still applies.
  6. Where questions turnAssuming money withdrawn from a TFSA can be put back the same year without using new room: withdrawn amounts are restored only on 1 January of the following year.
  7. The takeawayPut the most heavily taxed income in the tax-sheltered account and the most lightly taxed income outside it.
Practise Investment recommendations

IR-6Taxing capital gains and investment income

  • Capital gain = proceeds of disposition minus selling costs minus adjusted cost base (ACB); ACB includes the purchase price plus commissions. Identical shares bought at different times are averaged: ACB per share = total cost / total shares.
  • One half of a capital gain is included in income as a taxable capital gain and taxed at the marginal rate; one half of a capital loss is an allowable capital loss that can offset taxable capital gains only, carried back three years or forward indefinitely.
  • The superficial loss rule denies a loss if the same or identical property is bought within 30 days before or after the sale and still held 30 days after it; the denied loss is added to the ACB of the new shares.
  • Interest income is fully taxable at the marginal rate in the year earned, even if not yet received for some investments.
  • Eligible dividends from Canadian corporations are grossed up by 38% and earn a federal dividend tax credit of 15.0198% of the grossed-up amount; non-eligible dividends are grossed up by 15% with a federal credit of 9.0301%. Provincial credits are added on top.
  • Foreign dividends receive no gross-up or dividend tax credit and are fully taxable; foreign tax withheld can usually be claimed as a foreign tax credit in a non-registered account.
  • Tax minimization strategies include deferring gains, realizing losses to offset gains (while avoiding superficial losses), and holding investments in the account type that suits their tax treatment.
  1. The situationA client receives CAD 1,000 of eligible dividends, CAD 1,000 of non-eligible dividends and CAD 1,000 of interest. Assume a federal marginal rate of 29% and ignore provincial tax.
  2. Step 1Eligible: grossed-up amount = 1,000 x 1.38 = 1,380; tax = 1,380 x 29% = 400.20; credit = 1,380 x 15.0198% = 207.27; federal tax = 400.20 minus 207.27 = CAD 192.93.
  3. Step 2Non-eligible: grossed-up amount = 1,000 x 1.15 = 1,150; tax = 1,150 x 29% = 333.50; credit = 1,150 x 9.0301% = 103.85; federal tax = 333.50 minus 103.85 = CAD 229.65.
  4. Step 3Interest: federal tax = 1,000 x 29% = CAD 290.00.
  5. Step 4Separately, 500 shares bought at CAD 20 with a CAD 25 commission and sold at CAD 32 with a CAD 25 commission give ACB 10,025, net proceeds 15,975, a capital gain of 5,950 and a taxable capital gain of 5,950 / 2 = CAD 2,975.
  6. Where questions turnApplying the dividend tax credit rate to the cash dividend instead of to the grossed-up amount.
  7. The takeawayInterest is taxed most heavily, non-eligible dividends next, eligible dividends least, and only half of a capital gain is taxable.
Practise Investment recommendations

IR-7Handling client complaints

  • A complaint is any written or verbal expression of dissatisfaction from a client about a product, service, fee or the conduct of the firm or its staff; it must be recognized as such, even if informal.
  • Every complaint must be passed to the firm under its policies so it can be recorded and handled; a representative must never deal with a complaint privately or settle it without the firm.
  • CIRO dealers must acknowledge a complaint in writing promptly, generally within 5 business days, and give the client a substantive response, generally within 90 days, explaining the outcome and the client's further options.
  • If the client is not satisfied, or receives no response in time, the client may take the complaint to the Ombudsman for Banking Services and Investments (OBSI), which can recommend compensation up to CAD 350,000; clients may also complain to CIRO or pursue other remedies.
  • Firms report complaints and related information to CIRO, which uses the information to detect problems and decide whether to investigate.
  • Prohibited practices include requiring a client to withdraw a complaint to a regulator, or to keep the matter confidential from regulators or the police, as a condition of a settlement.
  1. The situationA client calls, upset that a fund she bought lost value, and says the representative never explained its risks. The representative offers to rebate his commission personally if she drops the matter.
  2. Step 1The client's statement is a complaint about the representative's conduct, even though it was made by phone.
  3. Step 2Offering a private payment to settle it is prohibited: complaints must go to the firm, and representatives may not settle them on their own.
  4. Step 3The firm must acknowledge the complaint in writing, investigate and give a substantive response within the required time.
  5. Step 4If she is not satisfied, she may go to OBSI, and the firm may not make any settlement conditional on her withdrawing a complaint to a regulator.
  6. Where questions turnDeciding a verbal complaint does not count: a complaint need not be in writing to be recognized and handled.
  7. The takeawayA complaint goes to the firm's process; a private deal by the representative is never acceptable.
Practise Investment recommendations

Key terms

Loss aversion
The tendency to feel losses more strongly than gains of the same size, which can lead clients to hold losing investments too long.
Anchoring
Relying too heavily on one reference point, such as a purchase price, when making decisions.
Cash flow analysis
A comparison of a client's income and expenses to find how much can be saved.
Annuity
A series of equal payments over a set number of periods, such as income drawn from a lump sum.
Adjusted cost base (ACB)
The tax cost of an investment, including purchase commissions and adjusted for events such as return of capital.
Taxable capital gain
The one half of a capital gain included in income.
Superficial loss
A capital loss denied because identical property was bought within 30 days before or after the sale and held 30 days after; it is added to the ACB of the new property.
Gross-up
The amount added to a Canadian dividend to approximate the corporation's pre-tax income: 38% for eligible dividends, 15% for non-eligible.
Dividend tax credit
A credit against tax on Canadian dividends, federally 15.0198% (eligible) or 9.0301% (non-eligible) of the grossed-up amount.
Attribution rules
Rules that tax income or gains on money given or lent to a spouse back to the person who provided it.
Capital dividend account
A private corporation's account of tax-free amounts, such as the non-taxable half of capital gains, which can be paid to shareholders as tax-free capital dividends.
Refundable dividend tax on hand
Part of a private corporation's tax on investment income that is refunded when it pays taxable dividends.
OBSI
The Ombudsman for Banking Services and Investments, an independent service that reviews unresolved complaints and can recommend compensation up to CAD 350,000.
After this guide: A client bought 100 shares at CAD 30 and later 200 at CAD 36, ignoring commissions. She sells all 300 at CAD 40. What is her taxable capital gain?
Show the answer

ACB = (100 x 30 + 200 x 36) / 300 = 10,200 / 300 = CAD 34.00 per share. Gain = 300 x (40 minus 34) = CAD 1,800. Taxable capital gain = 1,800 / 2 = CAD 900.

Practise Investment recommendations

Built to CIRO's Retail Securities Exam syllabus. The topics, explanations, worked examples and traps are ExamDragon's own. Every source this path is built on.