CIRO study sheet · CIRE · Element 6
Market integrity, trade execution and settlement
Canadian Investment Regulatory Organization (CIRO) Canadian Investment Regulatory Exam (CIRE) and Retail Securities Exam
13 questions on the CIRE · 6 topics · CIRO syllabus
Element 6 covers how trading is kept fair and how a trade gets done: UMIR's best execution, manipulation, front running, direct electronic access and principal trading rules, the gatekeeper obligations and how to apply them, the roles of investment banking, research and corporate finance, order entry, order types, corrections, confirmations, account types, margin, derivative account agreements and reporting duties. CIRO's syllabus gives it about 13 of the CIRE's 110 questions. Its questions test whether you recognize abusive or suspicious trading, know which order or account fits a situation, and know the steps from order to settlement; outcome 6.3 asks you to apply the gatekeeper rules to a scenario.
You should be able to: A client places a large buy order. Before entering it, a trader buys the same stock for his own account at the same price. Which two UMIR principles are at issue?
Every topic: the key point and the trap
- MI-1 UMIR: best execution, client priority and abusive trading
UMIR are CIRO's trading rules for every marketplace in Canada; they apply to dealers that are participants and to the people who trade through them.
Trap: Thinking best execution means only the best price: it weighs price with speed, certainty and total cost for the client.
- MI-2 Gatekeeping in practice
The gatekeeper obligations make dealers and their people the first line of defence for market integrity: they must not accept or execute orders they know or should reasonably know are manipulative, deceptive or otherwise in breach of UMIR or securities law.
Trap: Thinking a gatekeeper may enter a suspicious order because the client insists: knowing or having reason to suspect abuse means escalating rather than processing it.
- MI-3 Investment banking, research and corporate finance
Investment banking helps issuers raise capital and advises on mergers, acquisitions and restructurings; underwriting may be on a firm commitment or bought deal basis (the dealer buys the issue and carries the risk) or on a best efforts basis (the dealer sells as agent).
Trap: Confusing a bought deal with best efforts: in a bought deal the dealer has already bought the issue and bears the risk of not selling it.
- MI-4 Orders: entry, types, corrections and settlement
A market order trades immediately at the best available price, with certainty of execution but not of price; a limit order sets the worst acceptable price, with certainty of price but not of execution.
Trap: Saying Canadian equity trades still settle on T+2: they have settled on T+1 since 27 May 2024.
- MI-5 Confirmations, account types and margin
After each trade the dealer sends the client a confirmation promptly, showing the security, quantity, price, commission or other charges, the trade and settlement dates, and whether the firm acted as principal or agent.
Trap: Assuming an order-execution-only client gets suitability determinations: the dealer makes no recommendations and no suitability determinations on those trades.
- MI-6 Derivative account agreements and reporting obligations
Trading options or futures for a client requires a specialized account: an application with the client's knowledge and experience, a signed derivatives trading agreement, risk disclosure delivered to the client, and approval by a qualified supervisor before trading.
Trap: Believing a client can trade options in a regular cash account because he is experienced: the specialized agreement and approval are required first.
Key terms
- UMIR:
- The Universal Market Integrity Rules, CIRO's trading rules for all Canadian marketplaces.
- Best execution:
- The duty to diligently pursue the most advantageous terms reasonably available for a client order, weighing price, speed, certainty and cost.
- Client priority:
- The rule that a dealer may not trade for itself ahead of a client order at the same or a better price.
- Front running:
- Trading ahead of, or tipping others about, a pending client order likely to move the price.
- Wash trade:
- A trade with no change in beneficial ownership, used to create a false appearance of activity.
- Spoofing:
- Entering orders with no intention of executing them to mislead others about supply or demand.
- Gatekeeper:
- The role of dealers and their people in refusing and escalating orders they know or should know are abusive or illegal.
- Direct electronic access (DEA):
- An arrangement letting a qualified client send orders directly to a marketplace under a dealer's identifier and controls.
- Limit order:
- An order to trade at a set price or better, certain of price but not of execution.
- Fill-or-kill:
- An order that must be filled entirely and immediately or is cancelled.
- Iceberg order:
- A large order of which only part is displayed on the order book at a time.
- T+1:
- Settlement one business day after the trade date, the standard for Canadian equities and most long-term debt since 27 May 2024.
- Order-execution-only account:
- An account in which the dealer makes no recommendations and no suitability determinations.
- Margin call:
- A demand for more funds or securities when an account's margin falls below the requirement.
ExamDragon, examdragon.com/ciro. Independent exam preparation, not affiliated with, endorsed or reviewed by CIRO, Fitch Learning or the CSI; written in our own words to CIRO's CIRE syllabus. The exams' names are used only to identify them.
