Skip to content

Get the app

Study guide · CFE · Area 4

Audit and Assurance

4 sub-areas · 16 competencies · 5 topics

Audit and Assurance (area 4 of the 2022 CPA Competency Map) covers how an entity manages risk and control, which kind of assurance a user actually needs, and how an engagement is accepted, planned, performed, documented and reported under the Canadian Auditing Standards (CAS), CSQM 1 and 2, CSRE 2400, CSRS 4200 and the Canadian attestation standards, with independence and conduct governed by the CPA Code of Professional Conduct. CFE cases rarely ask you to name a standard. They give you an entity, its people and its numbers, and expect you to see the assurance issues yourself: advise on audit versus review versus compilation, spot an independence threat, calculate materiality on a sensible benchmark, identify specific risks at the assertion level from the facts, design procedures that answer those risks, judge whether evidence is enough, and say what the auditor's report would look like. Depth comes from using the case facts; generic lists of procedures earn little.

A study feature written by ExamDragon, not part of the real exam. CPA Canada publishes the area, its sub-areas and its competencies (listed below); the 5 topics are ours.

CPA Canada's 16 competencies for this area

4.1Internal Control

  1. 4.1.1Assesses the entity’s risk assessment processes
  2. 4.1.2Evaluates the information system, including the related processes, using knowledge of data requirements and risk exposures

4.2Internal and External Audit Requirements

  1. 4.2.1Advises on an entity’s assurance needs
  2. 4.2.2Explains the implications of current trends, emerging issues and technologies in assurance standards and methodologies

4.3Internal Audit Projects and External Assurance Engagements

  1. 4.3.1Assesses issues related to the undertaking of the engagement or project
  2. 4.3.2Assesses which set of criteria to apply to the subject matter being evaluated
  3. 4.3.3Assesses or develops which standards or guidelines to apply based on the nature and expectations
  4. 4.3.4Assesses materiality for the assurance engagement or project
  5. 4.3.5Assesses the risks of the project, or, for audit engagements, assesses the risks of material misstatement
  6. 4.3.6Develops appropriate procedures, including Audit Data Analytics (ADA), based on the identified risk
  7. 4.3.7Performs the work plan
  8. 4.3.8Evaluates the evidence and results of analysis
  9. 4.3.9Documents the work performed and its results
  10. 4.3.10Draws conclusions and communicates results
  11. 4.3.11Prepares or interprets information and reports for stakeholders using data visualization where appropriate

4.4Comprehensive Audit Projects

  1. 4.4.1Applies comprehensive auditing techniques

AA-1Internal control and information systems (4.1)

  • CAS 315 sets out five components of internal control: the control environment, the entity's risk assessment process, its process to monitor internal control, the information system and communication, and control activities.
  • In a small owner-managed entity the risk assessment process is often informal; the auditor understands it through discussion and judges whether its absence is a deficiency.
  • When the auditor finds a risk management missed, the auditor asks why the entity's process failed and whether that is a significant deficiency.
  • General IT controls (access, program change management, operations) support every application; application controls (edit checks, three-way matching, automated calculations) act on individual transactions.
  • Automated controls can be relied on only if general IT controls were effective for the period; with effective general IT controls a test of one instance per configuration is common.
  • Incompatible duties are a classic case issue: the person who processes payments should not maintain the vendor master file or reconcile the bank.
  • A control weakness recommendation in a case names the risk, its effect on the financial statements and a practical fix suited to the entity's size.
  1. The situationAt a distributor, the two payables clerks enter invoices, add new vendors and change vendor bank details. No one reviews master file changes, and payments are released automatically after a three-way match.
  2. Step 1Identify the weakness: one person can both create a vendor and process its payment.
  3. Step 2State the risk: a fictitious vendor, or a real vendor's bank details changed to a clerk's account, would be paid without detection.
  4. Step 3State the implication: expenses and cash could be misstated, and fraud losses would go unnoticed; the automated match does not help because the fake invoice can be matched to a fake order.
  5. Step 4Recommend: remove master file access from payables staff, and have someone independent review a monthly log of vendor changes against supporting documents.
  6. Where questions turnCalling an automated three-way match a general IT control. It is an application control; the general IT controls are the access and change controls that keep it working.
  7. The takeawayWeakness, implication, recommendation, tied to the facts: that is the structure a case marker looks for.
Practise Audit and Assurance

AA-2Assurance needs and the standards that apply (4.2, 4.3.2, 4.3.3)

  • Start with the user and the need: who will rely on the information, for what decision, and what level of assurance they require.
  • An audit (CAS) gives reasonable assurance and a positive opinion; a review (CSRE 2400) gives limited assurance, mainly from inquiry and analytical procedures, in a negative form of conclusion; a compilation (CSRS 4200) gives no assurance.
  • An agreed-upon procedures engagement reports factual findings from procedures the user specifies, and expresses no assurance.
  • Other subject matter falls under the Canadian attestation standards: CSAE 3000 generally, CSAE 3001 for direct engagements, CSAE 3410 for greenhouse gas statements and CSAE 3416 for controls at a service organization.
  • An audit of a single statement or a specific element follows the CAS adapted by CAS 805, with CAS 800 for special purpose frameworks.
  • Every assurance engagement needs suitable criteria: relevant, complete, reliable, neutral and understandable. For a covenant compliance report the criteria are the agreement's own definitions.
  • Audits of listed entities require key audit matters under CAS 701 and an engagement quality review under CSQM 1 and CSQM 2.
  • Data analytics, crypto-assets and AI models change how evidence is gathered but not the need to test the reliability of data (CAS 500) and to obtain evidence about rights, such as control of private keys.
  1. The situationA private company's bank asks for limited assurance on annual statements prepared under ASPE. A new equity investor will later want reasonable assurance, and the owner asks what to do now.
  2. Step 1Identify the users: the bank now, the investor later.
  3. Step 2Match need to engagement: limited assurance for the bank means a review under CSRE 2400.
  4. Step 3Flag the future need: when the investor arrives, an audit under CAS will be needed, and opening balances will then require work under CAS 510.
  5. Step 4Advise: a review now, with a note that auditing next year will cost more in the first year because of opening balances, so the owner may prefer to move to an audit early.
  6. Where questions turnSaying a compilation gives limited or negative assurance. It gives none.
  7. The takeawayAssurance advice ties the engagement to each user's need and anticipates changes the case hints at.
Practise Audit and Assurance

AA-3Planning and performing the engagement (4.3.1, 4.3.4 to 4.3.9)

  • Before accepting: preconditions under CAS 210 (an acceptable framework and management's acknowledgement of its responsibilities), competence under Rule 203, communication with the predecessor under Rule 302, and independence under Rule 204.
  • Independence threats are self-interest, self-review, advocacy, familiarity and intimidation; a direct financial interest of an engagement team member or immediate family, or a contingent fee for assurance (Rule 215), cannot be fixed with safeguards.
  • Materiality (CAS 320) uses a benchmark users care about: profit before tax for a stable profitable business (normalized for one-time items), revenue or expenses for a not-for-profit or a break-even entity. Performance materiality is set lower; lower levels may apply to sensitive items such as related party transactions.
  • Risks of material misstatement are assessed at the financial statement level (pervasive, such as a weak control environment) and at the assertion level (specific, such as revenue cut-off). Significant risks sit at the upper end of the spectrum of inherent risk.
  • CAS 240 presumes a fraud risk in revenue recognition (rebuttable with documented reasons) and always requires responses to management override: journal entry testing, a review of estimates for bias and a look at unusual transactions.
  • Procedures must answer the assertion: search for unrecorded liabilities for completeness of payables, confirmations and subsequent receipts for existence of receivables, sheet to floor for existence of inventory and floor to sheet for completeness.
  • Sample results are projected (CAS 530); deviations above the tolerable rate mean a control cannot be relied on; uncorrected misstatements are accumulated and evaluated (CAS 450), and an estimate outside the auditor's range is misstated at least to the nearest point (CAS 540).
  • Documentation (CAS 230) must let an experienced auditor with no connection to the audit understand what was done, on what, with what results; the final file is assembled after the report date and nothing may be deleted afterwards.
  1. The situationA manufacturer reports profit before tax of CAD 180,000 after a one-time lawsuit settlement of CAD 420,000. The firm uses 5% of normalized profit before tax and performance materiality of 75%.
  2. Step 1Normalize the benchmark: CAD 180,000 + CAD 420,000 = CAD 600,000.
  3. Step 2Materiality: CAD 600,000 x 5% = CAD 30,000.
  4. Step 3Performance materiality: CAD 30,000 x 75% = CAD 22,500.
  5. Step 4Explain the choice in the case: users (here the bank and owners) focus on sustainable earnings, and the settlement will not recur.
  6. Where questions turnListing generic procedures such as "test revenue". A useful procedure names the specific risk from the case, the assertion and the evidence source, for example vouching December shipments to bills of lading to test cut-off.
  7. The takeawayShow the benchmark, why it suits the users, the arithmetic and performance materiality; a bare number earns little.
Practise Audit and Assurance

AA-4Comprehensive audits and group engagements (4.4)

  • A comprehensive audit plan brings everything together: understanding of the entity, materiality, risks, the overall strategy and the procedures for each significant area.
  • In a group audit (CAS 600) the group engagement partner is responsible for the group opinion and directs, supervises and reviews work done at components, including by component auditors.
  • When a component auditor performs audit procedures, the group auditor sets a component performance materiality below group performance materiality, to allow for misstatements adding up across components.
  • The group auditor evaluates component auditors' competence and independence, communicates its requirements and evaluates the work and findings it receives.
  • Using others: internal auditors (CAS 610), an auditor's expert (CAS 620) and service organizations (CAS 402) each require the auditor to evaluate the work before relying on it.
  • Completion brings going concern (CAS 570), subsequent events up to the report date (CAS 560), written representations dated as near as practicable to but not after the report (CAS 580) and final analytical procedures (CAS 520).
  1. The situationA group has materiality of CAD 1,000,000. A foreign subsidiary audited by a component auditor reports misstatements of CAD 180,000, and two other components report CAD 240,000 and CAD 310,000.
  2. Step 1Aggregate the uncorrected misstatements: CAD 180,000 + CAD 240,000 + CAD 310,000 = CAD 730,000.
  3. Step 2Compare with group materiality: CAD 730,000 is 73% of CAD 1,000,000, below materiality but not far from it.
  4. Step 3Consider the risk of undetected misstatements in components where only limited work was done.
  5. Step 4Ask management to correct the misstatements and consider more work before concluding.
  6. Where questions turnAssuming the group auditor can simply rely on a component auditor's clean report without evaluating the component auditor's competence, independence and work.
  7. The takeawaySmall misstatements at several components can become material at group level, which is why component performance materiality is set lower than group performance materiality.
Practise Audit and Assurance

AA-5Conclusions, the auditor's report and communication (4.3.10, 4.3.11)

  • Unmodified opinion: the statements are presented fairly in all material respects.
  • Qualified opinion: a misstatement, or an inability to obtain evidence, that is material but not pervasive (CAS 705).
  • Adverse opinion: a misstatement that is material and pervasive. Disclaimer: an inability to obtain evidence whose possible effects are material and pervasive.
  • Going concern (CAS 570): material uncertainty adequately disclosed gives an unmodified opinion with a Material Uncertainty Related to Going Concern section; inadequate disclosure gives a qualified or adverse opinion; an inappropriate going concern basis gives an adverse opinion.
  • Key audit matters (CAS 701) are required for listed entities and are never a substitute for a modified opinion.
  • Emphasis of Matter (CAS 706) points to something properly disclosed and fundamental to users; Other Matter covers something not in the statements.
  • Significant deficiencies in internal control go in writing to those charged with governance on a timely basis (CAS 265); CAS 260 governs other communications with them.
  • When presenting results, choose visuals that match the message (trend over time, composition, comparison) and avoid charts that distort.
  1. The situationMateriality is CAD 100,000. Management refuses to write down obsolete inventory overstated by CAD 300,000; everything else is fairly presented.
  2. Step 1Is it material? CAD 300,000 exceeds CAD 100,000, so yes.
  3. Step 2Is it pervasive? It is confined to inventory and cost of sales and does not undermine the statements as a whole, so no.
  4. Step 3Opinion: qualified (except for), with a Basis for Qualified Opinion paragraph describing and quantifying the misstatement.
  5. Step 4Communicate the uncorrected misstatement to those charged with governance.
  6. Where questions turnUsing an Emphasis of Matter or a key audit matter in place of a qualification. Neither changes the opinion, and neither can fix a material misstatement.
  7. The takeawayTwo questions decide the report: material or not, pervasive or not, and whether the issue is a misstatement or a lack of evidence.
Practise Audit and Assurance

Key terms

Reasonable assurance
A high but not absolute level of assurance, the level obtained in an audit.
Limited assurance
A meaningful but lower level of assurance, obtained in a review engagement and expressed as a negative form of conclusion.
Compilation engagement
An engagement under CSRS 4200 to help management prepare financial information, giving no assurance.
Agreed-upon procedures
Procedures specified by the engaging party, with factual findings reported and no assurance expressed.
Suitable criteria
Benchmarks for evaluating a subject matter that are relevant, complete, reliable, neutral and understandable.
Materiality
The amount above which misstatements, alone or together, could reasonably be expected to influence users' economic decisions (CAS 320).
Performance materiality
An amount below overall materiality used to plan procedures, reducing the risk that uncorrected and undetected misstatements together exceed materiality.
Significant risk
A risk of material misstatement whose inherent risk is close to the upper end of the spectrum (CAS 315).
General IT controls
Controls over access, program changes and IT operations that support the continued functioning of application controls.
Application control
A control within a business process acting on individual transactions, such as an edit check or automated matching.
Management override
Management's ability to bypass controls, a fraud risk present in every entity and always a significant risk (CAS 240).
Key audit matter
A matter of most significance in the audit, selected from those communicated to those charged with governance, required for listed entities (CAS 701).
Emphasis of Matter paragraph
A paragraph drawing attention to a matter properly presented or disclosed that is fundamental to users' understanding (CAS 706).
Pervasive
Effects that are not confined to specific elements, or that are fundamental to users' understanding of the financial statements.
Self-review threat
The threat that a professional will not properly evaluate work they or their firm performed earlier, for example preparing records later audited.
Component auditor
An auditor who performs work on a component's financial information for a group audit, directed by the group auditor (CAS 600).
After this guide: A private retailer that uses ASPE has a material uncertainty about going concern because its main loan is due in four months with no refinancing agreed. Management's notes describe the uncertainty fully. The auditor also found an uncorrected misstatement of CAD 40,000 when materiality is CAD 120,000. What auditor's report is appropriate?
Show the answer

An unmodified opinion with a separate section headed Material Uncertainty Related to Going Concern (CAS 570), because the going concern basis is still appropriate and the uncertainty is adequately disclosed. The CAD 40,000 misstatement is below materiality, so on its own it does not modify the opinion, though the auditor asks management to correct it and considers it with any other uncorrected misstatements under CAS 450.

Practise Audit and Assurance

Built to CPA Canada's 2022 CPA Competency Map. The topics, explanations, worked examples and traps are ExamDragon's own. Every source this path is built on.