Skip to content

Get the app

Study guide · 2.1

Evidence, research and epidemiology

This topic covers how nurses use evidence to decide and improve care: the evidence-based practice process, focused clinical questions, levels of evidence, research designs, research ethics and consent, epidemiological rates, screening test values, and audit and quality improvement. Questions ask the nurse to frame a question, rank evidence, name a study design, protect a participant, calculate a rate or a test value, or choose the next step in an improvement cycle.

A study feature written by ExamDragon, not part of the real exam and not from OMSB. Evidence-Based Practice Including Research and Epidemiology is a domain of the OEN booklet; this topic inside it is ours.

1The evidence-based practice process and PICO

  • Evidence-based practice joins three things: the best available research, the nurse's clinical expertise, and the client's values and preferences, within the resources of the setting.
  • The process runs: ask a focused question, search for evidence, appraise it, apply it with the team and the client, then evaluate the result.
  • When nurses notice a practice problem, the first step is to write a focused, answerable clinical question.
  • PICO builds the question: Population or problem, Intervention, Comparison (often usual care) and Outcome; PICOT adds the Time frame.
  • A practice change goes through the unit's agreed process (appraisal, policy update, staff education and evaluation), not one nurse acting alone.
Worked example
  1. The situationA nurse writes: in adults with type 2 diabetes attending a primary health care centre, do weekly text message reminders, compared with usual follow-up, improve HbA1c at 6 months?
  2. Step 1Population: adults with type 2 diabetes attending the centre.
  3. Step 2Intervention: weekly text message reminders; Comparison: usual follow-up at the centre.
  4. Step 3Outcome: HbA1c, with a time frame of 6 months.
  5. Where questions turnCandidates mistake the comparison for the outcome, or the setting for the intervention.
  6. TakeawayName all four parts before you search.

2Levels and appraisal of evidence

  • For questions about treatment, systematic reviews and meta-analyses of randomised controlled trials sit at the top, then single randomised trials, then cohort and case-control studies, then case series and case reports, with expert opinion lowest.
  • A systematic review finds and appraises every relevant study by an explicit, repeatable method; a meta-analysis combines their results statistically into one estimate.
  • The best design depends on the question: questions about experience and meaning are best answered by qualitative studies.
  • Appraisal asks whether a study can be trusted: random allocation, blinding, an adequate sample, loss to follow-up and conflicts of interest.
  • Clinical guidelines built on systematic reviews are the usual route by which evidence reaches the bedside.
  • Habit (we have always done it this way) and the newest single study are weak bases for practice.
Worked example
  1. The situationA nurse educator is choosing evidence for a new pressure injury prevention protocol: an expert's opinion, a cohort study, a single randomised trial or a systematic review of randomised trials.
  2. Step 1Identify the question as one about the effect of an intervention.
  3. Step 2Rank the options by the hierarchy for treatment questions.
  4. Step 3Choose the systematic review of randomised controlled trials.
  5. Where questions turnThe newest or largest single trial is tempting, but combined, appraised evidence ranks higher.
  6. TakeawayFor treatment, a systematic review of trials comes first.

3Research designs

  • A randomised controlled trial allocates participants at random to an intervention or a comparison group; it is the strongest single design for showing that a treatment causes an effect.
  • A cohort study follows people with and without an exposure over time, forward from now or through past records, and compares how many develop the outcome; it measures incidence and relative risk.
  • A case-control study starts from people with a disease (cases) and without it (controls) and looks back at their past exposure; it suits rare diseases and gives an odds ratio.
  • A cross-sectional study measures exposure and disease at one point in time and gives prevalence.
  • Qualitative designs explore experience and meaning through interviews or focus groups with small purposive samples and report themes in the participants' own words.
  • The independent variable is the presumed cause, which the researcher changes or compares; the dependent variable is the outcome that is measured.
Worked example
  1. The situationResearchers identify 150 adults with oral cancer and 300 adults without cancer from the same region, then compare how many in each group chewed tobacco in the past.
  2. Step 1Note the starting point: whether people have the disease.
  3. Step 2See that the exposure is looked for in the past.
  4. Step 3Name it a case-control study.
  5. Where questions turnLooking back in time pushes candidates towards a cohort study, but a cohort starts from the exposure.
  6. TakeawayStart from the disease: case-control; start from the exposure: cohort.

4Research ethics and informed consent

  • Research with clients needs approval from a research ethics committee before any data are collected.
  • Consent to research is voluntary and informed: the participant is told the purpose, the procedures, the risks and benefits and the right to withdraw, and consent is documented.
  • Consent continues through the study: a participant may withdraw at any time, without giving a reason and with no effect on care.
  • A client who is sedated, in severe pain or otherwise without capacity is not asked to consent, and a relative does not consent for a competent adult.
  • The core principles are respect for persons, beneficence and justice, which includes fair selection of participants.
  • Protect confidentiality: code the data, store identifiers separately and report grouped results; the nurse acts as the participant's advocate and reports any concern to the research team or the ethics committee.
Worked example
  1. The situationA research assistant asks the nurse to obtain a client's signature on a study consent form. The client received the prescribed premedication with midazolam 20 minutes ago.
  2. Step 1Recognise that midazolam impairs understanding and memory.
  3. Step 2Decline and explain that consent must wait until the client is alert.
  4. Step 3Tell the research team so that consent is sought at another time.
  5. Where questions turnA signature can be collected, but it would not be valid consent.
  6. TakeawayNo capacity, no research consent.

5Epidemiology: rates and screening tests

  • Prevalence = number of existing cases, old and new, at a point in time / total population at that time; it shows the burden of disease.
  • Incidence = number of new cases during a period / population at risk at the start of the period (people without the disease); it shows the risk of developing the disease.
  • Prevalence is approximately incidence multiplied by the average duration of the disease, so it rises when incidence rises or when people live longer with the disease without cure.
  • In a two-by-two table, a = true positives, b = false positives, c = false negatives and d = true negatives; the disease status is in the columns and the test result in the rows.
  • Sensitivity = true positives / (true positives + false negatives) = a / (a + c); specificity = true negatives / (true negatives + false positives) = d / (b + d).
  • Positive predictive value = true positives / (true positives + false positives) = a / (a + b); negative predictive value = true negatives / (true negatives + false negatives) = d / (c + d); the positive predictive value falls when the condition is rare.
  • Attack rate = number who fall ill / number exposed, used in an outbreak; rates are expressed per 100, per 1,000 or per 100,000 people.
Worked example
  1. The situationA new screening test for gestational diabetes is compared with the glucose tolerance test in 500 pregnant clients: 40 true positives, 45 false positives, 10 false negatives and 405 true negatives.
  2. Step 1Place the counts: a = 40, b = 45, c = 10, d = 405.
  3. Step 2Sensitivity = 40 / (40 + 10) = 80%; specificity = 405 / (45 + 405) = 90%.
  4. Step 3Positive predictive value = 40 / (40 + 45) = 47.1%.
  5. Where questions turnReading across the row for sensitivity gives the predictive value instead.
  6. TakeawaySensitivity and specificity read down the columns; predictive values read across the rows.

6Audit, quality improvement and clinical guidelines

  • Clinical audit sets a standard, measures practice against it, makes changes and re-audits; the cycle is incomplete without the re-audit.
  • Research creates new knowledge, audit checks whether practice meets an agreed standard, and quality improvement tests changes to make care better.
  • Plan-Do-Study-Act tests a change on a small scale, studies the data and then adopts, adapts or abandons the change.
  • Quality indicators measure structure (resources and staffing), process (what is done, such as a documented risk assessment) and outcome (results for clients, such as the falls rate).
  • A run chart shows data over time; a sustained shift after a change shows association, not proof of cause, so monitoring continues.
  • A care bundle is a small set of evidence-based practices delivered together, every element every time.
  • Clinical guidelines are systematically developed recommendations; nurses follow them while adapting care to the individual client.
Worked example
  1. The situationA medical ward audits hand hygiene against the WHO's five moments and finds 62% compliance. The team runs teaching sessions and places alcohol hand rub at every bedside.
  2. Step 1Recognise that the audit cycle is not yet complete.
  3. Step 2Re-audit compliance against the same standard.
  4. Step 3Compare the new figure with 62% and plan the next cycle.
  5. Where questions turnStopping once the changes are made, or calling any improvement proof that the teaching caused it.
  6. TakeawayNo re-audit, no audit cycle.

Key terms

PICO
Population, Intervention, Comparison, Outcome: the parts of a focused clinical question.
Systematic review
A review that finds and appraises every relevant study using an explicit, repeatable method.
Meta-analysis
A statistical combination of the results of several studies into one overall estimate.
Randomised controlled trial
A study in which participants are allocated at random to an intervention or a comparison group.
Case-control study
A study that compares the past exposures of people with a disease and people without it.
Prevalence
The proportion of a population that has a condition at a given time.
Incidence
The rate of new cases of a condition in a population at risk over a stated period.
Sensitivity
The proportion of people with a condition whom a test correctly identifies as positive.
Specificity
The proportion of people without a condition whom a test correctly identifies as negative.
Clinical audit
A quality improvement cycle that measures care against a standard, changes practice and measures again.

Easy to confuse

  • Choosing habit or the newest single study as the basis for practice instead of appraised, combined evidence.
  • Confusing a cohort study, which starts from the exposure, with a case-control study, which starts from the disease.
  • Accepting a signed form from a sedated client, or a relative's signature for a competent adult, as research consent.
  • Mixing up the column and the row of a two-by-two table, or using the whole population instead of the population at risk for incidence.
  • Stopping after a change without re-auditing, or treating an improvement over time as proof of cause.

After this guide: You should be able to frame a PICO question, rank evidence, name a study design, protect a research participant's consent and confidentiality, calculate prevalence, incidence, sensitivity, specificity and predictive values, and use audit and PDSA cycles to improve care.

Practise 2.1 (15 questions)