Study guide · CIRE · Element 9
Conflicts of interest and ethics
16 of the CIRE's questions · 12 learning outcomes · 5 topics
Element 9 covers conflicts of interest and ethics: why conflicts matter, how a dealer identifies and addresses them in the client's best interest, the ethical and legal duties owed to clients, CIRO's standards of conduct, prohibited personal financial dealings, positions of influence, outside activities, client confidentiality, information barriers and cybersecurity. CIRO's syllabus gives it about 16 of the CIRE's 110 questions, the third largest share after elements 7 and 3. Its questions test judgement as much as recall: which conflict exists, what the client focused reforms require, and, under outcome 9.9, how to apply the outside activity rules to a specific situation.
A study feature written by ExamDragon, not part of the real exam. CIRO publishes the element, its question count and its learning outcomes (listed below); the 5 topics are ours and cover every outcome.
At a glance
Element 9of the CIRE's questions, CIRO's indicative count
- Questions
- 16
- Outcomes
- 12
- Topics
- 5
- Key terms
- 14
What this guide covers, topic by topic
CIRO's 12 learning outcomes for this element
- 9.1Understand the importance of an Investment Dealer managing conflicts of interest.
- 9.2Understand the process of conflicts of interest management.
- 9.3Understand an Investment Dealer's ethical and legal responsibilities to clients.
- 9.4Understand importance of ethics and how it relates to rules.
- 9.5Understand the importance of ethical principles and standards of conduct for Approved Persons and Investment Dealers.
- 9.6Understand CIRO and other ethical standards of conduct.
- 9.7Understand types of inappropriate or prohibited personal financial dealings with clients.
- 9.8Remember the requirements of employees and Approved Persons in respect of positions of influence.
- 9.9Apply the requirements governing an Approved Person's activities outside an Investment Dealer.
- 9.10Remember the requirements for Investment Dealers to have policies and procedures for maintaining client confidentiality.
- 9.11Understand the purpose and methods of controlling information.
- 9.12Understand the role of cybersecurity in the containment of confidential information.
CE-1Why conflicts matter and how they are managed
- A conflict of interest arises when the interests of the firm, an Approved Person or another client differ from a client's interests, or when they could influence advice or service.
- Unmanaged conflicts harm clients, damage trust in the firm and the market, and expose the firm and individuals to complaints, discipline and lawsuits.
- Under the client focused reforms, firms and registered individuals must identify existing material conflicts and those that are reasonably foreseeable, both at the firm and individual level.
- Each material conflict must be addressed in the client's best interest; a conflict that cannot be addressed that way must be avoided.
- Disclosure is required but is not enough on its own: it must be prominent, specific and clear and must explain the conflict, its effect and how it is controlled, but controls must also deal with the conflict itself.
- Common conflicts include compensation that rewards selling certain products, proprietary products, referral fees, gifts and entertainment, personal trading, and the firm's own underwriting or principal trading.
- The situationA firm pays representatives a higher payout for selling its own proprietary funds than third party funds with similar features and lower costs.
- Step 1The higher payout gives representatives an incentive that may not match clients' interests, a material conflict.
- Step 2Telling clients about the payout does not by itself resolve it.
- Step 3The firm must address it in clients' best interest, for example with product shelf reviews, neutral compensation, and supervision of whether the proprietary funds are actually the suitable choice.
- Step 4If the conflict cannot be controlled in clients' best interest, it must be avoided.
- Where questions turnBelieving that disclosing a conflict satisfies the rules: the client focused reforms require the conflict itself to be addressed in the client's best interest.
- The takeawayIdentify, then address in the client's best interest or avoid; disclosure alone is never the whole answer.
CE-2Ethics, rules and standards of conduct
- Dealers owe clients legal duties from securities law, CIRO rules, contract and common law, and in some relationships a fiduciary duty; ethics asks for more than the minimum the rules spell out.
- Rules cannot foresee every situation, so ethical principles fill the gaps: when a rule is silent or unclear, the right question is what serves the client and the integrity of the market.
- CIRO's standards of conduct require Approved Persons and dealers to deal fairly, honestly and in good faith with clients, observe high standards of ethics and conduct, and not engage in conduct that is unbecoming or harmful to the public interest.
- Core ethical principles include integrity, objectivity, competence, fairness, confidentiality, professionalism and diligence, putting the client's interest ahead of one's own.
- Other standards, such as professional designation codes of ethics, often apply as well; an Approved Person must meet the strictest that applies.
- Ethical lapses often begin with small rationalizations, such as 'everyone does it' or 'the client will never know', so a culture of compliance and escalation matters.
- The situationA representative notices that a rule technically allows a trade that would generate a large commission but clearly does not help the client.
- Step 1The rule being silent does not settle the matter.
- Step 2The standards of conduct require dealing fairly and in good faith, and suitability requires putting the client's interest first.
- Step 3A trade that serves the representative and not the client fails both tests.
- Step 4The ethical and compliant choice is not to recommend it.
- Where questions turnAssuming anything not expressly prohibited is acceptable: conduct unbecoming and the duty of fair dealing reach beyond specific rules.
- The takeawayWhen the rule is silent, ethics and the client's interest decide.
CE-3Personal financial dealings with clients
- Personal financial dealings with clients create conflicts and are restricted: the firm must have policies, and many dealings are prohibited outright.
- Prohibited or restricted dealings include borrowing money from or lending money to a client (with narrow exceptions such as a family member or a financial institution client, as firm policy allows), and paying a client or receiving money from a client outside the firm.
- An Approved Person must not guarantee a client against loss or compensate a client's losses personally; any settlement goes through the firm.
- Holding a client's power of attorney, acting as a client's trustee or executor, or otherwise having control over a client's financial affairs is generally not allowed, except for a related client under firm policy and approval.
- Sharing in a client's account, joint ventures or private investments with clients, and accepting gifts or benefits beyond what firm policy permits create conflicts that must be avoided or approved and controlled.
- Accepting a gift or bequest from a client, or being named in a client's will, raises serious concerns and must be reported to the firm.
- The situationA long-time client, unrelated to the representative, asks him to act as executor of her estate and offers him a small bequest for doing so.
- Step 1Acting as executor for an unrelated client gives him control over her financial affairs, which is generally prohibited.
- Step 2A bequest is a benefit from a client that creates a conflict.
- Step 3He should decline the executor role and report the offer to his supervisor under firm policy.
- Step 4He can suggest she consult a lawyer about choosing an executor.
- Where questions turnThinking a private loan to a client is acceptable because the client asked and signed a note: lending to clients is restricted regardless of the client's consent.
- The takeawayDo not take control of an unrelated client's affairs or accept benefits from clients outside firm policy; report and decline.
CE-4Positions of influence and outside activities
- A position of influence, such as being a director or officer of a public company or holding a role that gives sway over clients or public bodies, creates potential conflicts and requires disclosure to and approval by the firm.
- An Approved Person in a position of influence must not use it to obtain clients or business in a way that conflicts with their duties, must disclose material conflicts in writing, and must follow any client restrictions the firm imposes, such as limits on recommending that company's securities.
- Outside activities are any business or role outside the dealer, paid or unpaid, including employment, directorships, officer positions, volunteer roles that could raise conflicts, and holding a position of influence.
- Before starting an outside activity, the Approved Person must disclose it to the firm; the firm conducts due diligence on whether it creates conflicts, client confusion or time demands, approves or refuses it, and records the decision.
- Approved activities are reported to the regulators as the registration rules require, and the firm supervises them on an ongoing basis, with conditions where needed.
- Client confusion is a key risk: clients must not mistake the outside activity, or its products, for business of the dealer, and any product sold outside the firm is a serious concern.
- The situationA representative wants to join the board of a local credit union and also start selling insurance through a separate agency on weekends, serving some of her dealer clients.
- Step 1Both are outside activities, so she must disclose them to the firm before starting.
- Step 2The firm assesses each: the board seat may be a position of influence with conflicts over the credit union's products; the insurance work risks client confusion and conflicts over where clients' money goes.
- Step 3If approved, the firm sets controls, such as separate branding, disclosures to clients and supervision, and records its decision.
- Step 4The activities are then reported to the regulators as required, and she does not start until approval is given.
- Where questions turnStarting an unpaid volunteer role without telling the firm on the assumption that only paid work counts: outside activities include unpaid roles that could raise conflicts.
- The takeawayDisclose first, get approval, then operate under the firm's controls with clear separation to avoid client confusion.
CE-5Confidentiality, information barriers and cybersecurity
- Dealers must have policies and procedures to protect client confidentiality: client information is used only for the purposes the client consented to and is disclosed only with consent or as the law requires, consistent with PIPEDA.
- Firms control material non-public information so it is used only for legitimate purposes and never for trading or tipping, through information barriers (sometimes called firewalls) between areas such as investment banking and sales, trading and research.
- A grey list (watch list) is a confidential list of issuers about which the firm holds sensitive information; compliance monitors trading in those issuers without alerting staff.
- A restricted list names issuers where trading, solicitation or research is limited, for example during an offering the firm is underwriting; it is known to staff because it limits what they may do.
- Crossing an information barrier ('wall crossing') happens only with compliance's approval, and the person brought over the wall is then restricted.
- Cybersecurity protects confidential client and firm information: firms need governance, risk assessment, staff training, access controls, incident response plans and vendor oversight, and must report cybersecurity incidents to CIRO promptly.
- Representatives protect information day to day by using firm-approved systems, guarding against phishing and social engineering, and never sending client data through personal email or apps.
- The situationA research analyst asks a colleague in investment banking whether the firm is working on a deal involving a company he covers.
- Step 1Deal information is material non-public information held behind the information barrier.
- Step 2The banker must not share it informally.
- Step 3If the analyst's input is truly needed, compliance can approve a wall crossing, after which the analyst is restricted.
- Step 4Compliance may also place the company on the grey list to monitor trading quietly.
- Where questions turnConfusing the grey list with the restricted list: the grey list is confidential and watched by compliance, while the restricted list is known to staff and limits their activity.
- The takeawayInformation barriers are crossed only through compliance, and grey lists are monitored quietly while restricted lists limit activity openly.
Key terms
- Conflict of interest
- A situation where the interests of the firm, an Approved Person or another client differ from, or could influence service to, a client.
- Material conflict
- A conflict that could reasonably be expected to affect the client's decisions or the firm's or individual's recommendations.
- Client's best interest
- The standard under the client focused reforms for addressing conflicts and making suitability determinations.
- Standards of conduct
- CIRO's requirement to deal fairly, honestly and in good faith and observe high standards of ethics and conduct.
- Conduct unbecoming
- Behaviour that harms the public interest or the reputation of the industry, which CIRO can discipline even without a specific rule breach.
- Position of influence
- A role, such as a public company directorship, that could give an Approved Person sway over clients or others and create conflicts.
- Outside activity
- Any business, role or position outside the dealer, paid or unpaid, that must be disclosed, assessed and approved.
- Client confusion
- The risk that clients mistake an outside activity or its products for the dealer's business.
- Power of attorney
- Legal authority to act for another person; an Approved Person generally may not hold one for an unrelated client.
- Information barrier
- Policies and controls that keep material non-public information within the area that needs it.
- Grey list
- A confidential list of issuers about which the firm holds sensitive information, monitored by compliance.
- Restricted list
- A list of issuers in which trading, solicitation or research is limited, known to staff.
- PIPEDA
- The federal privacy law governing how private sector organizations collect, use and disclose personal information.
- Cybersecurity incident
- An event that threatens the confidentiality, integrity or availability of a firm's systems or data, which must be reported to CIRO.
Show the answer
She must disclose it to her firm, which assesses it as an outside activity and a likely position of influence, then approves or refuses it and records the decision before she starts; it is reported to the regulators as required. The firm must address the conflict over recommending or trading that company's shares for clients, for example with written disclosure, restrictions and supervision.
Built to CIRO's CIRE syllabus. The topics, explanations, worked examples and traps are ExamDragon's own. Every source this path is built on.
