Skip to content

Get the app

Study guide · CIRE · Element 3

Scope of client relationships

17 of the CIRE's questions · 17 learning outcomes · 7 topics

Element 3 covers what an Investment Dealer and its people may do for clients once the relationship exists: the roles of the Registered Representative and the Investment Representative, trust, agency and fiduciary duty, relationship disclosure, the services retail and institutional dealers offer, account appropriateness, product due diligence and know your product, suitability for retail and institutional clients and its exemptions, escalation to experts, investment management styles, benchmarks, and clients outside Canada. It is the second largest CIRE element, with about 17 of the 110 questions in CIRO's syllabus. Its questions test whether you can tell who may do what, which obligation applies in a given account or situation, and how the obligations differ.

A study feature written by ExamDragon, not part of the real exam. CIRO publishes the element, its question count and its learning outcomes (listed below); the 7 topics are ours and cover every outcome.

CIRO's 17 learning outcomes for this element
  1. 3.1Understand the role of the Registered Representative in providing client service.
  2. 3.2Understand the role of the Investment Representative in providing client service.
  3. 3.3Understand the concepts of trust, agency and fiduciary duty and when relevant
  4. 3.4Understand the purpose and content of the relationship disclosure.
  5. 3.5Remember the typical services provided by retail Investment Dealer.
  6. 3.6Remember the typical services provided by institutional Investment Dealers.
  7. 3.7Understand the applicability of account appropriateness obligation.
  8. 3.8Understand the applicability of product due diligence obligation on:
  9. 3.9Understand the applicability of know-your-product (KYP) obligation to understand all investments purchased, sold or...
  10. 3.10Understand the difference between account appropriateness and account suitability determination.
  11. 3.11Understand the applicability of client suitability determination requirements for retail clients.
  12. 3.12Understand the applicability of assessment of an institutional client's sophistication level and...
  13. 3.13Remember the exemptions from suitability determination requirements.
  14. 3.14Remember why internal escalation procedures to subject matter experts may be required.
  15. 3.15Remember systematic approaches to investment management and clients' investment strategies.
  16. 3.16Understand the use of relevant investment performance benchmarks.
  17. 3.17Remember the procedures and requirements for working with clients residing in the United States and other...

SC-1The Registered Representative and the Investment Representative

  • A Registered Representative (RR) may make recommendations, gather KYC information, apply the suitability determination and, with the approvals the rules and the firm require, manage client portfolios; RRs can serve retail clients, institutional clients or both, depending on their approval.
  • An Investment Representative (IR) may answer client enquiries, give quotes, provide general pre-order information about products and accounts, take and enter orders, report trades and help correct errors, but may not make recommendations.
  • The line between information and a recommendation matters: an IR may explain what a product is and how it works, but may not tell a client what to buy, sell or hold.
  • An IR who receives an order that appears clearly unsuitable for the client should raise the concern and follow the firm's escalation procedures rather than advise the client what to do instead.
  • Both roles are Approved Persons subject to CIRO's standards of conduct, supervision, proficiency and continuing education requirements.
  1. The situationA client calls an IR and asks: "Should I sell my bank shares and buy the new technology ETF?"
  2. Step 1The question asks for a recommendation, which an IR may not give.
  3. Step 2The IR may provide factual information: current quotes, how the ETF works, its fees and where to find its documents.
  4. Step 3If the client wants advice, the IR refers the client to an RR.
  5. Step 4If the client decides on his own and gives an order, the IR can take and enter it.
  6. Where questions turnTreating a suggestion phrased as "many clients are buying this" as mere information: steering a client toward a specific trade is a recommendation, which an IR may not make.
  7. The takeawayIRs inform and execute; only RRs recommend.
Practise Scope of client relationships

SC-2Trust, agency, fiduciary duty and relationship disclosure

  • When a dealer executes a client's order on a marketplace it typically acts as agent, buying or selling on the client's behalf for a commission; when it sells from or buys into its own inventory it acts as principal, which creates a conflict that must be disclosed and addressed.
  • Trust underlies the relationship: clients rely on the firm and representative for honest information and for handling their money and securities properly.
  • A fiduciary duty, the highest duty in law, requires acting with loyalty and in the other person's best interest; courts may find one where a client is vulnerable and relies heavily on an adviser, for example where the adviser has discretionary authority or effective control over the account.
  • Whether or not a fiduciary duty arises, registrants must deal fairly, honestly and in good faith, address conflicts in the client's best interest and make suitability determinations that put the client's interest first.
  • The relationship disclosure explains the products and account types available, any limits on what the firm offers (such as offering mainly proprietary products), fees and compensation, how the account operates, how suitability is assessed (by account, household or portfolio) and what reports the client will receive.
  1. The situationA firm offers only its own family of mutual funds in a particular account type. What must the client be told?
  2. Step 1The product limitation affects what the client can buy, so it is part of relationship disclosure.
  3. Step 2Offering only proprietary products is also a conflict of interest that the firm must address in the client's best interest.
  4. Step 3The firm must explain the limitation and its effect in plain language before the client opens the account.
  5. Step 4The representative still makes a suitability determination for each investment action within that shelf.
  6. Where questions turnAssuming every adviser always owes a fiduciary duty: a fiduciary duty depends on the facts, such as reliance and control, while the regulatory duties apply to every client.
  7. The takeawayProduct shelf limits must be disclosed up front, and they do not lower the suitability standard.
Practise Scope of client relationships

SC-3Services offered by retail and institutional dealers

  • Order execution only (OEO) accounts let clients trade without recommendations from the firm; the firm does not make suitability determinations in them, although it still verifies identity, collects basic information and meets other obligations.
  • Advisory accounts give clients recommendations from an RR, with each investment decision made by the client and each recommendation subject to suitability.
  • Managed accounts give a portfolio manager discretionary authority to make investment decisions for the client within an agreed mandate, under a written agreement; discretionary accounts more generally are accounts in which authorized staff can trade without obtaining the client's approval for each trade, subject to approval and supervision requirements.
  • Institutional dealers offer trading and sales, equity and fixed income research, underwriting of new issues, mergers and acquisitions advice, prime brokerage (financing, custody and clearing for hedge funds and other active traders) and securities lending.
  • The service model chosen shapes which obligations apply: suitability does not apply in an OEO account, while a managed account carries the fullest discretionary responsibility for the firm.
  1. The situationA self-directed investor wants low commissions and makes all her own decisions, while her brother wants someone to run his portfolio day to day.
  2. Step 1The sister's needs fit an order execution only account: no recommendations and no suitability determinations, which keeps costs low.
  3. Step 2The brother wants decisions made for him, which requires a managed or discretionary account with written authority and the related approvals.
  4. Step 3An advisory account sits between them: recommendations, with the client deciding.
  5. Step 4Each choice should be checked for account appropriateness against the client's needs.
  6. Where questions turnThinking an OEO firm has no obligations at all: it still verifies identity, meets AML rules, deals fairly and must not make recommendations.
  7. The takeawayMatch the service to who makes the decisions: the client alone (OEO), the client with advice (advisory) or the manager (managed or discretionary).
Practise Scope of client relationships

SC-4Account appropriateness, product due diligence and know your product

  • Account appropriateness asks whether the type of account and service, such as fee-based or commission-based, advisory or managed, fits the client's needs and circumstances; it is assessed when an account is opened and when circumstances change.
  • Suitability, by contrast, asks whether a particular investment action (a purchase, sale, hold, transfer or other decision) is suitable for the client; an account can be appropriate while a specific trade in it is not suitable.
  • Product due diligence is the Investment Dealer's obligation to assess and approve the securities it makes available, and to monitor them for significant changes, before its Approved Persons recommend them.
  • Know your product (KYP) is the Approved Person's obligation to understand each security recommended or bought and sold for a client: its structure, features, risks, initial and ongoing costs, and the impact of those costs.
  • A firm must also take reasonable steps to understand how the products it offers compare with similar products available in the market, and Approved Persons must not recommend a product they do not understand or that the firm has not approved.
  1. The situationA client in a fee-based account paying 1.5% a year trades twice a year and holds mostly GICs and a few bond funds.
  2. Step 1Account appropriateness: a 1.5% annual fee for an account with very little activity and low-risk holdings may cost far more than a commission-based account would.
  3. Step 2The firm should consider whether a different account type better serves the client's interest.
  4. Step 3Separately, each holding still needs a suitability determination, and the representative must understand each product and its costs (KYP).
  5. Step 4Appropriateness and suitability are distinct checks, and both must be met.
  6. Where questions turnTreating firm approval of a product as satisfying the representative's KYP obligation: the firm's due diligence and the individual's understanding of the product are separate duties.
  7. The takeawayAppropriateness concerns the account and service; suitability concerns each investment action.
Practise Scope of client relationships

SC-5Suitability, institutional assessment, exemptions and escalation

  • For retail clients, the firm must determine that an investment action is suitable, based on the client's KYC information, the product (KYP), the account's concentration and liquidity, the impact of costs and a reasonable range of alternatives, and that it puts the client's interest first, before acting on it.
  • Suitability is assessed when the firm recommends or takes an investment action and is reviewed on triggering events such as a transfer of assets into the account, a change of representative, a material change in KYC information, and a significant market event affecting the account.
  • For an institutional client, the firm assesses whether the client has the sophistication to make its own investment decisions; where the client is assessed as able to and has confirmed it, the firm's suitability obligation is reduced.
  • Suitability determination does not apply to order execution only accounts, to institutional clients as the rules allow, or to permitted clients who have waived it in writing (except in managed accounts).
  • Firms escalate to internal experts, such as options or derivatives supervisors and product specialists, when a product or situation is complex, for example approving an options account or reviewing a concentrated or leveraged strategy.
  1. The situationA new client transfers CAD 600,000 of securities from another dealer, including 45% of the portfolio in one small-cap stock.
  2. Step 1A transfer of assets into an account is a suitability trigger, so the representative reviews the portfolio promptly.
  3. Step 2The 45% concentration is a red flag for the client's risk profile and liquidity needs.
  4. Step 3The representative discusses the concentration with the client and documents the advice and the client's decision.
  5. Step 4If complex holdings such as options positions are involved, the review is escalated to the appropriate supervisor or specialist.
  6. Where questions turnBelieving a retail client in an advisory account can sign a waiver of suitability: waivers are limited to permitted clients outside managed accounts.
  7. The takeawaySuitability is reviewed on triggering events, not only when a new trade is recommended.
Practise Scope of client relationships

SC-6Investment management styles and benchmarks

  • Passive bond management aims to match an index or hold bonds to maturity, using approaches such as buy and hold, bond laddering and indexing; it seeks low cost and predictable cash flows rather than outperformance.
  • Active bond management tries to add value by forecasting interest rates and adjusting duration, by moving between sectors or credit qualities, or by exploiting yield curve shifts and mispriced bonds.
  • Passive equity management tracks a market index, usually through index funds or ETFs, at low cost; active equity management selects securities or sectors to beat a benchmark, using styles such as value, growth, sector rotation or market timing.
  • A benchmark is the yardstick for judging performance; it should match the portfolio's asset class, region, style and risk, such as the S&P/TSX Composite Index for broad Canadian equities or the FTSE Canada Universe Bond Index for broad Canadian bonds.
  • A balanced portfolio is best judged against a blended benchmark weighted like its asset mix, for example 60% of an equity index plus 40% of a bond index.
  1. The situationA portfolio of 70% Canadian equities and 30% Canadian bonds returned 6.0% last year; the S&P/TSX Composite returned 9.0% and the FTSE Canada Universe Bond Index returned 2.0%.
  2. Step 1Comparing with the equity index alone (9.0%) would make the portfolio look weak, but that benchmark does not match the mix.
  3. Step 2Blended benchmark: 0.70 x 9.0% + 0.30 x 2.0% = 6.3% + 0.6% = 6.9%.
  4. Step 3The portfolio's 6.0% trailed the blended benchmark by 0.9 percentage points.
  5. Step 4That is the fair measure of how the manager did for this mandate.
  6. Where questions turnJudging a balanced or conservative portfolio against an all-equity index: the benchmark must reflect the portfolio's actual asset mix and risk.
  7. The takeawayUse a benchmark that matches the portfolio's mix and style, blending indexes where needed.
Practise Scope of client relationships

SC-7Clients in the United States and other foreign jurisdictions

  • Securities law generally applies where the client is located, so a Canadian firm and representative may deal with a client living in the United States or another country only if they are registered there or can rely on an exemption.
  • In the United States this usually means registration with the SEC and FINRA and with the relevant state, or reliance on a specific exemption, such as relief that allows Canadian dealers to service certain Canadian registered retirement accounts of clients who have moved to the United States.
  • Firms set procedures for foreign clients: identifying a client's residence, restricting what representatives may do for clients in jurisdictions where the firm is not registered, and supervising any cross-border dealings.
  • Representatives should not solicit, recommend or accept new business from clients in a foreign jurisdiction unless the firm's procedures confirm it is permitted.
  • Foreign residence also affects tax and reporting, such as the self-certification of tax residence that firms collect for international tax information exchange.
  1. The situationA long-time client moves from Calgary to Seattle and asks her representative to buy shares in her non-registered account.
  2. Step 1The client now resides in the United States, so US federal and state securities law applies to dealings with her.
  3. Step 2The representative checks the firm's procedures: unless the firm and representative are registered or an exemption covers this account and activity, they may not solicit or accept the trade.
  4. Step 3The account record is updated for her new residence and tax status.
  5. Step 4If the firm cannot service her, it helps her move the account to an appropriately registered dealer.
  6. Where questions turnAssuming a Canadian registration lets a representative keep advising a client who has moved abroad: the client's new jurisdiction's rules govern.
  7. The takeawayWhen a client moves abroad, the firm must be registered or exempt where the client now lives before it keeps dealing with her.
Practise Scope of client relationships

Key terms

Registered Representative (RR)
An Approved Person who may make recommendations to clients, collect KYC information, make suitability determinations and, with approvals, manage portfolios.
Investment Representative (IR)
An Approved Person who may give quotes and product information and take orders, but may not make recommendations.
Agent
A dealer acting on the client's behalf, for example buying or selling on a marketplace for a commission.
Principal
A dealer trading from or into its own inventory with the client, which creates a conflict that must be addressed and disclosed.
Fiduciary duty
A legal duty of loyalty to act in another person's best interest, which a court may find where a client is vulnerable and relies on an adviser who has discretion or control.
Order execution only (OEO)
A service in which the firm executes the client's own decisions without making recommendations or suitability determinations.
Managed account
An account in which a portfolio manager makes investment decisions under discretionary authority granted in a written agreement.
Account appropriateness
The assessment of whether the type of account and service suits the client's needs and circumstances.
Know your product (KYP)
The obligation to understand each security's structure, features, risks and costs before recommending or trading it.
Product due diligence
The dealer's assessment, approval and monitoring of the securities it makes available to clients.
Suitability trigger
An event that requires a suitability review, such as a transfer into the account, a change of representative, a material KYC change or a significant market event.
Bond ladder
A passive bond strategy that spreads holdings evenly across maturities and reinvests each maturing bond at the long end.
Blended benchmark
A performance yardstick built by weighting several indexes in the same proportions as the portfolio's asset mix.
After this guide: A client is in a commission-based advisory account that suits his occasional trading. His RR recommends a structured note the firm approved last month but that the RR has not yet studied. Which obligations are in play, and is the recommendation acceptable?
Show the answer

Account appropriateness is met, and the firm has done product due diligence by approving the note. But the RR has not met his own KYP obligation, so he cannot make a proper suitability determination. The recommendation is not acceptable until he understands the note's structure, risks and costs and determines it is suitable and puts the client's interest first.

Practise Scope of client relationships

Built to CIRO's CIRE syllabus. The topics, explanations, worked examples and traps are ExamDragon's own. Every source this path is built on.