Skip to content

Get the app

CIRO study sheet · CIRE · Element 9

Conflicts of interest and ethics

Canadian Investment Regulatory Organization (CIRO) Canadian Investment Regulatory Exam (CIRE) and Retail Securities Exam

16 questions on the CIRE · 5 topics · CIRO syllabus

Element 9 covers conflicts of interest and ethics: why conflicts matter, how a dealer identifies and addresses them in the client's best interest, the ethical and legal duties owed to clients, CIRO's standards of conduct, prohibited personal financial dealings, positions of influence, outside activities, client confidentiality, information barriers and cybersecurity. CIRO's syllabus gives it about 16 of the CIRE's 110 questions, the third largest share after elements 7 and 3. Its questions test judgement as much as recall: which conflict exists, what the client focused reforms require, and, under outcome 9.9, how to apply the outside activity rules to a specific situation.

You should be able to: A representative wants to accept an unpaid seat on the board of a small public company whose shares several of her clients hold. What must happen before she accepts, and what client concern must the firm address?

Every topic: the key point and the trap

  1. CE-1 Why conflicts matter and how they are managed

    A conflict of interest arises when the interests of the firm, an Approved Person or another client differ from a client's interests, or when they could influence advice or service.

    Trap: Believing that disclosing a conflict satisfies the rules: the client focused reforms require the conflict itself to be addressed in the client's best interest.

  2. CE-2 Ethics, rules and standards of conduct

    Dealers owe clients legal duties from securities law, CIRO rules, contract and common law, and in some relationships a fiduciary duty; ethics asks for more than the minimum the rules spell out.

    Trap: Assuming anything not expressly prohibited is acceptable: conduct unbecoming and the duty of fair dealing reach beyond specific rules.

  3. CE-3 Personal financial dealings with clients

    Personal financial dealings with clients create conflicts and are restricted: the firm must have policies, and many dealings are prohibited outright.

    Trap: Thinking a private loan to a client is acceptable because the client asked and signed a note: lending to clients is restricted regardless of the client's consent.

  4. CE-4 Positions of influence and outside activities

    A position of influence, such as being a director or officer of a public company or holding a role that gives sway over clients or public bodies, creates potential conflicts and requires disclosure to and approval by the firm.

    Trap: Starting an unpaid volunteer role without telling the firm on the assumption that only paid work counts: outside activities include unpaid roles that could raise conflicts.

  5. CE-5 Confidentiality, information barriers and cybersecurity

    Dealers must have policies and procedures to protect client confidentiality: client information is used only for the purposes the client consented to and is disclosed only with consent or as the law requires, consistent with PIPEDA.

    Trap: Confusing the grey list with the restricted list: the grey list is confidential and watched by compliance, while the restricted list is known to staff and limits their activity.

Key terms

Conflict of interest:
A situation where the interests of the firm, an Approved Person or another client differ from, or could influence service to, a client.
Material conflict:
A conflict that could reasonably be expected to affect the client's decisions or the firm's or individual's recommendations.
Client's best interest:
The standard under the client focused reforms for addressing conflicts and making suitability determinations.
Standards of conduct:
CIRO's requirement to deal fairly, honestly and in good faith and observe high standards of ethics and conduct.
Conduct unbecoming:
Behaviour that harms the public interest or the reputation of the industry, which CIRO can discipline even without a specific rule breach.
Position of influence:
A role, such as a public company directorship, that could give an Approved Person sway over clients or others and create conflicts.
Outside activity:
Any business, role or position outside the dealer, paid or unpaid, that must be disclosed, assessed and approved.
Client confusion:
The risk that clients mistake an outside activity or its products for the dealer's business.
Power of attorney:
Legal authority to act for another person; an Approved Person generally may not hold one for an unrelated client.
Information barrier:
Policies and controls that keep material non-public information within the area that needs it.
Grey list:
A confidential list of issuers about which the firm holds sensitive information, monitored by compliance.
Restricted list:
A list of issuers in which trading, solicitation or research is limited, known to staff.
PIPEDA:
The federal privacy law governing how private sector organizations collect, use and disclose personal information.
Cybersecurity incident:
An event that threatens the confidentiality, integrity or availability of a firm's systems or data, which must be reported to CIRO.

ExamDragon, examdragon.com/ciro. Independent exam preparation, not affiliated with, endorsed or reviewed by CIRO, Fitch Learning or the CSI; written in our own words to CIRO's CIRE syllabus. The exams' names are used only to identify them.