Skip to content

Get the app

Study guide · Physician activity

Communication

10% target (ours) · 8 sections

Communication covers every interaction a physician has with patients, families, caregivers, other professionals, communities and populations. On the MCCQE it is a smaller activity, but the questions are often missed. Items ask what you should say or do next in a hard conversation: bad news, an error, consent, a language barrier, or a disagreement with a family. The best answer is honest, respectful and centred on the patient. It asks before it tells, and it checks understanding.

A study feature written by ExamDragon, not part of the real exam. The domain and its definition are the MCC's; the teaching, examples and traps are ours, tied to the current Canadian guidelines listed at the end.

1Breaking bad news

  • Prepare: a private place, enough time, and the right people present if the patient wants them.
  • Start by asking what the patient already knows or suspects.
  • Ask how much detail they want now. Some want everything, some want a little at a time.
  • Give a warning shot, then the news in plain words. Avoid jargon and long explanations at first.
  • Pause and respond to emotion. Name the feeling and allow silence.
  • End with a plan and the next contact. The patient should not leave without knowing what happens next.
  1. A worked exampleA 54-year-old man returns for his biopsy result, which shows lung cancer. The best first step is to ask what he understands about why the biopsy was done. Then, after a warning, give the result simply and wait for his reaction before talking about treatment.
  2. Where questions turnDo not open with statistics and treatment options. First find out what the patient knows and wants to know.
Practise

2Disclosure of adverse events

  • Patients have a right to know when harm or possible harm happened during their care.
  • Disclose as soon as reasonably possible, once the patient is stable and ready.
  • Say what happened in facts known so far, what is being done, and what will happen next.
  • Say you are sorry the event happened. Most provinces have apology laws, so an apology is not an admission of legal liability.
  • Do not guess at causes or blame other people. Promise to share more as the review finds it.
  • Report the event through the hospital's safety system, and contact the Canadian Medical Protective Association for advice.
  1. A worked exampleA 66-year-old woman received a double dose of an anticoagulant because of an order error. She has minor bruising and is stable. The best step is to tell her clearly what happened, say you are sorry, explain the monitoring plan, and report the event. Waiting until the incident review ends is not appropriate.
  2. Where questions turnDo not delay disclosure until all the facts are known, and do not hide a mistake because no lasting harm occurred.
Practise

3Informed consent conversations

  • Explain the nature of the treatment, its expected benefits, material risks, side effects and reasonable alternatives, including no treatment.
  • Material risks include common risks and rare but serious ones that a reasonable person in the patient's position would want to know.
  • Use plain words and check understanding by asking the patient to explain back in their own words.
  • Answer questions honestly and give time to decide when the situation allows.
  • Consent must be voluntary. Family pressure or coercion makes it invalid.
  • The person who will do the procedure is responsible for making sure consent is informed.
  1. A worked exampleA 47-year-old woman is booked for a laparoscopic cholecystectomy. She signed the form but asks the physician what 'bile duct injury' means. The best response is to explain the risk in plain words, its likelihood, and how it would be managed, then confirm she still wants to proceed.
  2. Where questions turnDo not treat a signed form as consent. Consent is the conversation and the patient's understanding, not the paper.
Practise

4Interpreters and language barriers

  • When the patient and physician do not share a language well, use a trained medical interpreter, in person, by phone or by video.
  • Avoid using family members, and never children, as interpreters for clinical decisions. They may filter or change the message.
  • Speak directly to the patient, not to the interpreter. Use short sentences and pause often.
  • Check understanding with teach-back through the interpreter.
  • Sign language users have the same right to a qualified interpreter.
  • Document that an interpreter was used and how.
  1. A worked exampleA 39-year-old woman who arrived in Canada as a refugee 3 months ago needs consent for surgery. Her 12-year-old son speaks English well and offers to translate. The best step is to arrange a professional interpreter, by phone if no one is available in person.
  2. Where questions turnDo not accept a child or relative as interpreter because it is faster. Consent obtained that way may not be valid.
Practise

5Cultural safety with Indigenous patients

  • Cultural safety means the patient decides whether care feels safe and respectful, free of racism and discrimination.
  • Colonial history, residential schools and racism in health care shape trust. The Truth and Reconciliation Commission called on health systems to address this.
  • Ask the patient what matters to them, including traditional healing, family roles and ceremony, and include these when the patient wishes.
  • Offer Indigenous patient navigators or liaisons where they exist.
  • Avoid assumptions about substance use or adherence. Ask every patient the same questions in the same way.
  • Reflect on your own biases. Listen more than you speak.
  1. A worked exampleA 50-year-old First Nations man with diabetes has missed several visits. Staff note he is 'non-compliant'. The best step is to ask him, without judgement, what makes visits hard, such as travel distance or past experiences, and to plan care that works for him.
  2. Where questions turnDo not label a patient as non-compliant or explain a problem by identity. Ask about barriers, as you would for any patient.
Practise

6Families, caregivers and substitute decision-makers

  • A capable adult controls who receives their health information. Ask before sharing with family.
  • When the patient lacks capacity, speak with the substitute decision-maker named by provincial law.
  • The substitute decision-maker must follow the patient's known prior capable wishes. If none apply, they decide in the patient's best interests.
  • Explain that the decision-maker is speaking for the patient's wishes, not their own preferences.
  • In conflict, listen, find the shared goal, and offer a family meeting with the team.
  • Caregivers can be important partners. Ask how they are coping and offer support.
  1. A worked exampleA 79-year-old man with a severe stroke cannot communicate. His son wants every treatment, but the patient had a written advance directive refusing intubation. The best step is a family meeting explaining that his capable written wish guides the decision.
  2. Where questions turnDo not follow the loudest family member. The legal substitute decision-maker must apply the patient's known wishes first.
Practise

7Interprofessional handover and teamwork

  • Handover passes responsibility for a patient to another clinician. Errors in handover cause harm.
  • Use a structured tool such as SBAR: situation, background, assessment and recommendation.
  • Name pending results, outstanding tasks and what to watch for.
  • Invite questions and confirm the receiver understands. Do it face to face or by phone when possible.
  • Speak up about safety concerns, whatever your role. Respect the expertise of nurses, pharmacists and other team members.
  • Disagree in private and with facts, not in front of the patient.
  1. A worked exampleAt the end of a night shift, a resident hands over a 73-year-old woman with a potassium of 6.1 mmol/L, a repeat level pending in 1 hour. The best handover states the problem, the treatment given, the pending result and the action needed if it is still high.
  2. Where questions turnDo not leave a critical pending result off the handover. A test you ordered stays your responsibility until someone else clearly takes it over.
Practise

8Difficult and angry conversations

  • Stay calm and listen first. Let the person finish before you reply.
  • Acknowledge the emotion without becoming defensive.
  • Find out the real concern behind the anger, such as fear or waiting too long.
  • Say what you can and cannot do, and offer a clear next step.
  • If there is a risk of violence, keep yourself and others safe and call for help.
  1. A worked exampleA 45-year-old woman shouts that her father has waited 6 hours in the emergency department. The best response is to acknowledge her frustration, explain where he is in the process, check whether his condition has changed, and say when someone will update them.
  2. Where questions turnDo not argue or explain hospital policy at length first. Acknowledge the feeling, then address the concern.
Practise

Key terms

Warning shot
A short phrase that prepares a person for bad news, such as 'I am afraid the result is not what we hoped'.
Disclosure
Telling a patient openly that harm or possible harm happened during their care.
Material risk
A risk a reasonable person in the patient's position would want to know before deciding.
Teach-back
Asking the patient to explain in their own words what they understood.
Cultural safety
Care that the patient feels is respectful and free of racism; judged by the patient.
Substitute decision-maker
The person who makes health decisions for a patient who lacks capacity, named by provincial law.
SBAR
A handover structure: situation, background, assessment, recommendation.
Advance directive
A patient's earlier written or spoken wishes about future health care.

The guidelines this guide rests on

  • Medical Council of Canada, Qualifying Examinations Blueprint and Content Specifications, 2014
  • Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada, CanMEDS 2015 Physician Competency Framework, 2015
  • Canadian Patient Safety Institute, Canadian Disclosure Guidelines: Being Open with Patients and Families, 2011
  • Canadian Medical Protective Association, guidance on disclosure of patient safety incidents and informed consent
  • Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada, Calls to Action, 2015
  • Canadian Medical Association, CMA Code of Ethics and Professionalism, 2018
  • Provincial health care consent and substitute decision-making legislation (named generically)
After this guide: After this guide you can choose the response that is honest, patient centred and safe in the hard conversations the MCCQE tests: bad news, errors, consent, language barriers, families and handover.
Practise

Built to the MCC's blueprint for the MCCQE. The explanations, worked examples and traps are ExamDragon's own. Every source this path is built on. MCCQE is a mark of the Medical Council of Canada, which does not endorse or review this product.