Study guide · Physician activity
Professional behaviours
10% target (ours) · 8 sections
Professional behaviours are the attitudes, knowledge and skills that make a physician competent, ethical and trustworthy. They include clinical and administrative competence, communication and ethics. On the MCCQE this activity tests Canadian ethical and legal duties: consent, capacity, confidentiality and its limits, truth telling, boundaries, negligence, documentation and medical assistance in dying. Questions describe a dilemma and ask what the physician should do. The best answer respects the patient, follows the law, and is honest. Because laws differ by province, the exam tests principles that hold across Canada.
A study feature written by ExamDragon, not part of the real exam. The domain and its definition are the MCC's; the teaching, examples and traps are ours, tied to the current Canadian guidelines listed at the end.
At a glance
Physician activityof the exam, our working target (the MCC's weighting is not yet read)
- Target
- 10%
- Sections
- 8
- Key terms
- 8
What this guide covers, section by section
1Consent and capacity
- Valid consent is informed, voluntary, given by a capable person, and specific to the treatment.
- Adults are presumed capable. Capacity is specific to each decision and can change over time.
- A capable person can understand the information relevant to the decision and appreciate how it applies to them.
- A capable patient may refuse any treatment, even life-saving treatment, for any reason.
- In most provinces there is no fixed age of consent: a minor who has capacity can consent. Quebec sets an age of 14 for most care.
- In an emergency, a physician may treat without consent if delay would cause serious harm, unless they know the patient refused that treatment while capable.
- A worked exampleA 34-year-old woman who is a Jehovah's Witness has heavy bleeding after delivery. She is alert and capable, and she clearly refuses blood products after hearing the risk of death. The physician must respect the refusal and use every other treatment available.
- Where questions turnDo not equate a refusal you disagree with to a lack of capacity. Capacity depends on understanding and appreciation, not on the choice.
2Confidentiality and its legal limits
- Patient information is confidential. Share it only with consent, with the circle of care when implied consent applies, or when the law requires or permits.
- Child protection: every province and territory requires a report when a physician has reasonable grounds to suspect a child is in need of protection. You report yourself and you do not need proof.
- Fitness to drive: most provinces require physicians to report patients whose medical condition may make driving unsafe; others permit it.
- Reportable diseases must be reported to public health under provincial law.
- Gunshot wounds, and in some provinces stab wounds, must be reported to police in many provinces. The report is limited, usually the patient's name and the facility.
- Courts allow disclosure without consent when there is a clear, serious and imminent danger to an identifiable person or group. Disclose only what is needed to prevent harm.
- A worked exampleA 4-year-old girl has bruises of different ages on her back and a story that does not fit. Her mother says she fell. The physician should report to the child protection agency now, without waiting for proof and without needing the mother's permission.
- Where questions turnDo not investigate or confront the family to be sure first, and do not ask a colleague to report for you. Reasonable suspicion is enough and the duty is yours.
3Truth telling
- Patients have a right to honest information about their health.
- When family asks you to hide a diagnosis, explore their concern, then ask the patient how much they want to know and who should be told.
- A patient may choose not to know, or to let someone else receive the information. Respect that choice when it is the patient's.
- Withholding information to protect the patient is allowed only in very rare cases where telling would cause serious, immediate harm.
- Be honest about uncertainty and about errors.
- Never deceive a patient, including with placebos presented as active treatment.
- A worked exampleThe son of an 82-year-old capable woman asks the team not to tell her she has pancreatic cancer. The best step is to acknowledge his wish to protect her, then ask the patient privately how much she wants to know about her results.
- Where questions turnDo not agree to keep a capable patient uninformed because family asks. The patient decides how much to hear.
4Boundaries and conflicts of interest
- Sexual or romantic relationships with a current patient are never allowed. Rules for former patients are set by provincial law and college policy.
- Avoid treating yourself or family members, except for minor or emergency problems when no one else is available.
- Small gifts of thanks may be accepted. Decline large gifts or any gift that could affect care.
- Declare any financial interest in a test, treatment or referral. The patient's interest comes first.
- Interactions with industry must not influence prescribing. Free meals, trips or payments tied to prescribing are not acceptable.
- Social media contact with patients blurs boundaries. Keep professional communication in professional channels.
- A worked exampleA 40-year-old man, a long-time patient, asks his family physician out for dinner. The best response is to decline kindly, explain the professional boundary, and continue to provide care.
- Where questions turnDo not think that ending care makes any relationship acceptable at once. College rules on former patients still apply.
5Negligence and the standard of care
- Negligence needs four elements: a duty of care, a breach of the standard of care, harm, and the breach caused the harm.
- The standard of care is what a reasonable and prudent physician with similar training would do in similar circumstances.
- A bad outcome alone is not negligence. An error of judgement within reasonable practice is not negligence.
- In Canada, informed consent follows a modified objective test: what a reasonable person in the patient's position would want to know (Reibl v Hughes, 1980).
- Failing to follow up a test result you ordered can be a breach of the standard of care.
- When a complaint or legal action is possible, contact the Canadian Medical Protective Association and do not alter records.
- A worked exampleA 48-year-old woman had a chest X-ray ordered for cough. The report noted a nodule, but no one reviewed it, and cancer was found a year later. The ordering physician had a duty to review and act on the result. This is a likely breach of the standard of care.
- Where questions turnDo not equate an unexpected complication with negligence. Ask whether the care met the standard, not whether the outcome was bad.
6Documentation and medical records
- Write notes at the time of care or soon after: findings, reasoning, plan, and what the patient was told.
- Never change or delete a past entry. Add a dated, signed late entry or correction instead.
- Document consent discussions, refusals and the use of an interpreter.
- Patients have a right to access their own records, with narrow exceptions such as a risk of serious harm.
- Keep records secure. Do not look up records of people you are not caring for, including colleagues or family.
- Clear notes protect the patient and the physician.
- A worked exampleAfter an adverse outcome, a resident realises she forgot to document a phone call with the patient the day before. The best step is to add a late entry with today's date and time, clearly labelled, describing the call.
- Where questions turnDo not write the note as if it were made at the earlier time. Altering records is a serious professional failure.
7Medical assistance in dying and conscientious objection
- Medical assistance in dying (MAID) is legal in Canada under the federal Criminal Code, with eligibility criteria and safeguards in the law.
- Key criteria include age 18 or older, capacity, eligibility for publicly funded health services, a grievous and irremediable medical condition, a voluntary request and informed consent.
- The law and its criteria have changed over time. Always check the current federal criteria and provincial processes.
- A physician may decline to take part for reasons of conscience.
- A physician who objects must not abandon the patient. College policies require timely access, and some, such as Ontario's, require an effective referral to a willing provider or agency.
- Do not impose your beliefs or delay the patient's access to information.
- A worked exampleA 69-year-old man with advanced ALS asks his family physician about MAID. The physician objects for religious reasons. The best response is to tell him respectfully, and to make sure he is connected without delay to a provider or coordinating service, as college policy requires.
- Where questions turnDo not refuse to discuss MAID and leave the patient without a path. Conscientious objection does not end the duty of care.
8Physician wellness and impaired colleagues
- Physician burnout and illness are common and affect patient safety. Seeking help is part of professionalism.
- Provincial physician health programs offer confidential support for physicians with health or substance use problems.
- If a colleague appears impaired at work, protect patients first: make sure they do not continue providing care at that moment.
- Report concerns through the proper channel, such as the department head or the physician health program.
- Provincial law and college policy may require a report to the regulator when a colleague's condition puts patients at risk. Some provinces require reporting sexual abuse of patients by a regulated health professional.
- Treat the colleague with respect. The aim is safety and recovery, not punishment.
- A worked exampleDuring a night shift, a nurse tells a resident that the attending smells of alcohol and is slurring words before a procedure. The best step is to make sure the attending does not perform the procedure, get another qualified physician, and report through the department chain.
- Where questions turnDo not ignore impairment to protect a colleague, and do not confront them in front of patients. Patient safety comes first.
Key terms
- Capacity
- The ability to understand information about a decision and appreciate its consequences for oneself.
- Circle of care
- The health providers directly caring for a patient, who may share information under implied consent.
- Reasonable grounds to suspect
- A belief based on facts that a reasonable person would hold; proof is not needed.
- Standard of care
- What a reasonable and prudent physician with similar training would do in similar circumstances.
- Negligence
- A breach of the standard of care that causes harm to a patient who was owed a duty.
- Conscientious objection
- Declining to provide a service because of personal moral or religious beliefs.
- Effective referral
- A referral made in good faith to a willing, available and accessible provider or agency.
- Physician health program
- A confidential provincial service that helps physicians with health or substance use problems.
The guidelines this guide rests on
- Medical Council of Canada, Qualifying Examinations Blueprint and Content Specifications, 2014
- Canadian Medical Association, CMA Code of Ethics and Professionalism, 2018
- Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada, CanMEDS 2015 Physician Competency Framework, 2015
- Canadian Medical Protective Association, guidance on consent, confidentiality, documentation and duty to report
- Provincial child protection, public health, highway traffic and health care consent legislation (named generically)
- Criminal Code of Canada, provisions on medical assistance in dying
- Provincial college policies on medical assistance in dying, conscientious objection and boundaries (named generically)
- Supreme Court of Canada, Reibl v Hughes, 1980; Smith v Jones, 1999
Built to the MCC's blueprint for the MCCQE. The explanations, worked examples and traps are ExamDragon's own. Every source this path is built on. MCCQE is a mark of the Medical Council of Canada, which does not endorse or review this product.
